Choosing Between Elvie Curve and Haakaa? I’ve used both, and even though they look alike, they feel very different. The Elvie Curve is soft, hands-free, and comfy to wear. The Haakaa, on the other hand, gives strong suction without needing a pump.
As a mom who’s nursed through long days and late nights, I know what works when life gets messy. If you want a no-fluff guide that’s real, simple, and helpful—you’re in the right spot. Let’s find the one that fits your flow best.
Is Elvie Curve Good?
Yes, the Elvie Curve is a great hands-free option if you want to collect let-down milk without much effort. I started using it early on, when every drop of milk felt like gold. I didn’t expect much from this soft, silicone pump—but it surprised me.
One night while nursing, I slipped the Elvie Curve into my bra on the other side. I wasn’t doing anything fancy—just letting my let-down flow. In that short time, I got almost two ounces without trying. It sat snug in my bra with no squeezing, no wires, and no noise. Since it’s reusable, I also felt good about using less waste.
It’s super helpful for moms in the U.S. who return to work early and need to save milk. Whether you’re at home or out running errands, it doesn’t draw attention. It’s quiet, comfy, and easy to wear—even while multitasking.
The Elvie Curve is made from soft, BPA-free silicone and holds up to 4 oz. It’s simple to use and quick to clean, which really helps when you’re running on little sleep.
What I Like
- Hands-free and silent: I can wear it while nursing or even doing dishes. It fits in my bra and makes no noise. That freedom to move is a huge win.
- Discreet and comfy: I’ve used it in the car, at the store, and in waiting rooms. No one noticed. It’s easier than a manual pump and doesn’t need batteries.
- Catches milk I’d lose: I didn’t realize how much milk I was wasting before. This little pump helped me save it with zero stress. It became a daily habit, especially in those first few months.
What Could Be Better
- Not for full pumping sessions: This isn’t a full-time pump. It’s made to catch let-down, not replace an electric pump or build a big stash.
- No suction control: The gentle suction is comfy, but not strong. If you need more pull, this might not be enough.
- Pricey for what it is: It’s not the cheapest. The Haakaa is more budget-friendly. But I chose comfort, and for me, it was worth the extra cost.
Recommendation
If you leak during let-down or want to save milk while nursing, the Elvie Curve is a smart pick. It’s perfect for moms who juggle a lot and need an easy, no-fuss way to catch milk.
But if you need strong suction or want to pump full sessions, this may not be enough. You might pair it with a main pump for the best of both worlds.
For me, the Elvie Curve fits real mom life. It’s simple, smart, and made my breastfeeding days easier. I’m glad I had it in my kit.
👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿
Is Haakaa Good?
Yes, the Haakaa is great—especially if you want a quiet and easy way to collect let-down milk. I started using it with my second baby and quickly wished I’d found it sooner.
One night during a late feeding, I attached it to the other side while nursing. When my baby finished, I had saved almost two ounces—without effort. It’s perfect for building a stash without pulling out a full pump.
Made from soft, food-grade silicone, it’s comfy, quick to clean, and easy to carry. No wires. No setup. No batteries. Just squeeze and let it work. That simple design is what made me fall in love with it.
What I Like
- No cords or noise: I use it without plugs, tubes, or sounds. It’s perfect for nights or when I’m out.
- Gentle and soft: The silicone feels nice and never hurt my skin. It stayed on well after I placed it.
- Saves let-down milk: I used to waste milk into pads. Now I save those drops—and they add up fast.
What Could Be Better
- No volume lines: It’s hard to tell how much milk is inside. I had to guess unless I poured it out.
- Suction can slip: If I moved too much, the suction could pop off—especially with a wiggly baby.
- Not for full sessions: This is great for let-down, but not strong enough to fully empty your breast. I still needed an electric pump when I went back to work.
Recommendation
If you’re nursing and want a hands-free way to catch extra milk, the Haakaa is a must-have. It’s a lifesaver in the early weeks when your supply is finding balance and every drop counts.
It’s best for stay-at-home moms or those saving milk before returning to work. Just know it’s not a full pump. If you need stronger suction or want to pump often, you’ll still want a good electric option too.
For me, the Haakaa was simple, smart, and always in my diaper bag. I wouldn’t go through those early months without it.
👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿
Detailed Comparison: Elvie Curve vs Haakaa
I’ve used both the Elvie Curve and the Haakaa over the course of my breastfeeding journey. Each one helped me in different ways. If you’re torn between these two, here’s a friendly, honest breakdown based on real use.
Suction Control: Elvie Curve vs Haakaa
Both use natural suction, but how they apply and hold suction feels different.
| Feature | Elvie Curve | Haakaa |
| Suction Type | Gentle, controlled with pressure | Stronger, passive suction |
| Adjustability | Manual pressure adjustment | No control—just squeeze and attach |
| Comfort Level | More comfortable for longer wear | Can feel tight if suction is strong |
Rating: Elvie Curve – 9/10 | Haakaa – 8/10
Portability: Elvie Curve vs Haakaa
Both are compact, but there are key differences in how discreet and spill-proof they are on the go.
| Feature | Elvie Curve | Haakaa |
| Size | Slim, fits in bra easily | Bulky tip may peek through shirt |
| Spill Risk | Minimal due to flatter shape | Easier to spill if bumped |
| Discreetness | Very discreet under clothing | Less discreet in public settings |
Rating: Elvie Curve – 9/10 | Haakaa – 7/10
Milk Collection: Elvie Curve vs Haakaa
The design of each tool affects how well it collects milk during letdown or feeding.
| Feature | Elvie Curve | Haakaa |
| Capacity | 4 oz | 4–5 oz |
| Collection Speed | Slower due to gentle suction | Fast, especially during letdown |
| Leak Resistance | Leak-proof with tight seal | Can leak if not positioned well |
Rating: Elvie Curve – 8/10 | Haakaa – 9/10
Cleaning Ease: Elvie Curve vs Haakaa
Keeping things clean matters, especially with newborn routines.
| Feature | Elvie Curve | Haakaa |
| Parts to Clean | One-piece silicone | One-piece silicone |
| Dishwasher Safe | Yes | Yes |
| Dry Time | Quick due to compact shape | Quick |
Rating: Elvie Curve – 10/10 | Haakaa – 10/10
Material Quality: Elvie Curve vs Haakaa
When it comes to baby products, material safety and durability are big deals.
| Feature | Elvie Curve | Haakaa |
| Material | BPA-free, food-grade silicone | BPA-free, food-grade silicone |
| Feel | Smooth, firm silicone | Softer, flexible silicone |
| Durability | Very durable | Slightly more prone to wear |
Rating: Elvie Curve – 9/10 | Haakaa – 8/10
Performance: Elvie Curve vs Haakaa
Here’s how they perform when you’re multitasking or just trying to get a quiet moment.
| Feature | Elvie Curve | Haakaa |
| Letdown Catching | Excellent when feeding on opposite | Fastest results during letdown |
| Usability While Feeding | Great for wearing in bra | Best when attached before letdown |
| Spill-proof | Yes | Not always |
Rating: Elvie Curve – 9/10 | Haakaa – 8/10
Ease of Use: Elvie Curve vs Haakaa
Both are simple, but small design details make a difference when you’re running on little sleep.
| Feature | Elvie Curve | Haakaa |
| Setup Time | Instant—just press and insert | Instant—squeeze and attach |
| Learning Curve | None | None |
| Day-to-Day Use | Feels more comfortable and natural | Can be fiddly during re-positioning |
Rating: Elvie Curve – 9/10 | Haakaa – 8/10
Value for Money: Elvie Curve vs Haakaa
When you factor in cost and what you get out of it, the story changes a bit.
| Feature | Elvie Curve | Haakaa |
| Price | Higher (~$50) | Affordable (~$12–20) |
| Long-Term Use | Worth it for daily multitasking | Great for occasional use |
| Replacement Need | Rare | Might need replacement over time |
Rating: Elvie Curve – 8/10 | Haakaa – 10/10
Read More: Elvie Stride vs Elvie Stride Plus
Overall: Elvie Curve vs Haakaa
If I had to pick just one, it would depend on my daily routine. Elvie Curve fits smoothly into busy days, while Haakaa works fast and is budget-friendly.
| Feature | Elvie Curve | Haakaa |
| Best For | On-the-go, discreet pumping | Home use during feeding |
| Strengths | Comfort, discreetness, ease | Simplicity, price, fast suction |
| Limitations | Price | Less discreet, spills more easily |
Rating: Elvie Curve – 9/10 | Haakaa – 8.5/10
👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿
FAQs: Elvie Curve vs Haakaa
The Elvie Curve uses gentle pressure and fits in your bra. The Haakaa uses strong suction to pull milk out. Each one works best in different ways.
The Haakaa is better if you have a strong letdown and want to save more milk. The Elvie Curve is good for quiet, easy use while nursing.
Yes, you can use both while feeding. The Elvie Curve fits in your bra. The Haakaa sticks to the other breast using suction.
The Elvie Curve is soft and smooth under clothes. The Haakaa feels tighter because it grips with suction.
Both are simple to clean. But the Haakaa has fewer parts and can go in the dishwasher.
